Small Like a Sparrow

Even the sparrow has found a home… Psalm 84:3

Menu

Skip to content
  • Home
  • A Walk in the Woods Archive
  • About
November 14, 2026 by Lara Mather

The Unsolved Death of a Biblical Counselor

For most of my life, it was a mystery to me why people would watch true crime documentaries. As a little kid, I got the shivers watching Scooby Do. My imagination has always been good at coming up with ways that I might die. I haven’t needed extra plot lines with suspenseful background music. But then, somehow, the Kouri Richins trial showed up on my YouTube feed. And then another trial, and another, and before you know it, I’m subscribed to The Lawyer You Know and Courtroom Insider, and I’m one of those middle-aged women who wash dishes while court is in session on the windowsill above the sink.

And it makes sense to me. I’ve been learning the rules of the courtroom. Who speaks when and what questions are allowed to be asked. There are two tables where the defense and the prosecution sit separately. You know who is on which side and what they are aiming for with their questions and carefully procured evidence. There’s a jury watching intently and they are legally committed to following procedures to keep their minds open to the truth presented. There are expert witnesses. There’s a judge who sits up higher than the rest with a clear view of the courtroom and with the power to stop nonsense when it happens. I love it. Our justice system is so beautiful. I’m sure it’s imperfect and corrupt at times (like so many other places we want to be pure and good). But in a courtroom, we find the means and procedures and people who can take something that is dark, purposefully confusing to onlookers, and even evil, and bring to it the powers of light, clarity and, eventually, justice.

It probably is not coincidental that I fell in love with our justice system while an unsuspected and confusing death scene was approaching in my career as a biblical counselor. I am still alive, breathing in the early winter air and taking in the beauty of November’s soft colors and bold lines. But I can look inside and see a part of myself behind yellow crime scene tape. That part who saw herself as a biblical counselor is faceup on the ground, arms and legs askew, and lifeless. The true-crime drama might start with flashbacks to me as a younger mom, homeschooling my kids and taking graduate classes one by one by one for five years to earn a seminary degree in counseling. There would be interviews with people close to me who remember how much it meant to me to intern at and then start working for an organization I had long respected. Witnesses would say, “She loved her life, her work, her counselees and she had future forward thinking. It doesn’t make sense. How can she just be gone?” Investigators would be asking the first question at any death scene, “What happened?” And the answers wouldn’t be clear as the clues are still being searched out.

Have you ever experienced something like this? Part of you, or maybe a relationship, or a dream you had that meant something, could be encircled with yellow police tape and called a potential crime scene? And maybe you don’t even fully understand what happened. The evidence is still in a state of confusion. Was this death by natural causes, or self-inflicted or maybe there was foul play?

But one thing we do know for sure; when someone or something dies, whether we can isolate the cause or not, it hurts. Some of us might go numb for a bit or minimize the significance of what we are grieving, saying, “It’s nothing compared to what others face.” Other people are persistent investigators, pouring through any available data, wanting to get to the bottom of what happened in order to learn and grow, to be safe, or maybe to seek justice. Some of us get rip roaring angry. And there are those among us who feel the sadness through tears that won’t stop, like those weeping witnesses that make it necessary to put the court in recess for a while.

For me, while there have been moments of all of those responses, it’s mostly been a slow, quiet heaviness. When I resigned, I gave myself a long off-ramp to be sure I could finish well with each counselee. It was early July, warm and sunny, when I knew the biblical counselor in me was carrying something terminal. My last session was at the end of October, at just the time of the year when here in New England the darkness has outpaced the light, and our days are short.

On a walk one day, close to the end, amid all the brown and still-orange-tinged leaves on the ground, my eye caught sight of a papery white leaf, looking either like lace or like a skeleton. I felt a surprising connection, thinking, “Oh… that’s me. That’s a self-portrait. It’s just how I feel.” I bent to take a picture noticing how fragile the leaf looked there on the ground, and was aware that it would soon just disappear. Dust to dust. Once, attached to a tall tree, it held the bright green of early spring. It had always been comforting to me in late fall, when seeing bare branches, to know that in the spring there would be new green leaves. But that day, it felt wrong that there would be replacements. It only heightened the sorrow I felt for this leaf. She was not going to be green ever again. She’d never be up high, waving in a warm breeze. It was over for her.

And then, something happened. Maybe the biblical counselor stirred a bit inside. A little reviving vital sign, because it was as though she whispered, “Resurrection. Remember, our God is the resurrecting God.” And standing there in the brown woods, I imagined God reaching down and placing that fragile, lacey, skeleton of a leaf in his strong hand. I saw him breathing over her, remaking her cells and turning her as green as springtime. And I realized with wonder, He really could do it if he chose.

What would it be like to watch a true-crime show and to have this be the ending? Can you imagine if in the last episode there was a “Jesus calling into a tomb to raise Lazarus” scene? What if the one who was dead showed up, took a deep breath and gave an interview? Actually, if we believe what the Bible says, don’t all crime documentaries we see today end with the middle of the story? More is coming. More breath, more life, more truth.

I don’t know what “more” looks like for the biblical counselor inside of me. Lately, I’ve tried to take steps toward some of the doors that have opened- having fallen off one tree, I’m noticing that there’s actually a forest surrounding me. I couldn’t see it well when I was clinging so hard to the branch on which I’d grown, but the things I have loved about knowing and caring for people could continue in other contexts. The only problem I’m running into is that there’s still a body behind police tape inside. And while true crime has made its way in, I still don’t see myself watching zombie movies anytime soon. I don’t want to be the walking dead. I really can’t be.

But I’m going to take the lesson of the leaf and wait. He doesn’t forget her and only care about preserving the tree with the strong branches preparing to cast out greenery again in the spring. God is so big that he bends low and cares for even the discarded leaf. And while he might let her turn to soil and bring new life in that way, he does promise his children resurrection. That might be a far-off ultimate reality for us bodily, but I feel it today like a slight heartbeat, a small inhale, interrupting my mourning and my inability to conjure up life. He can do what I cannot. So, I’m asking him to breathe over my life in ways that wake what he wants to awake and sooth into peace the parts that need rest.

If there are ways that you have experienced loss and I can pray for you, please let me know. I’ll pray as I walk in the woods under bare branches. Also, as I’m sorting through the clues to understand what happened behind the yellow tape in my own life, if you have a story to share of how you have been helped, or maybe hurt, by biblical counseling, I would be honored to read your story and be a witness, whether in joy or weeping.

With a deep inhale,

Lara

Posted in Small Like a Sparrow | Tagged biblical counseling | 1 Comment

Contact Me

laramather.blog@gmail.com

Search

Follow Blog via Email

Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Archives

Powered by WordPress.com.
Loading Comments...